|
Border
Security Strategies from the Kitchen
By Paul A. Ibbetson
(Published
in May 2006 by News By Us)
"Clean your plate!" Remember this parental mantra?
It is likely that you, like most children, underwent this unique
educational experience. For parents, using the kitchen as a classroom;
that is, teaching children to “clean their plate” (eat all their food)
was a lesson that goes far beyond simple grocery economics. In reality,
parents teach their children the valuable ethics of responsibility -
children learn that both lunch and life are full of tasks that must be
completed. Furthermore, the plate cleaning process teaches children to
take personal responsibility for finishing a given task. Parents teach
their children to focus their attention not on the “plate cleaning”
status of other siblings, but on taking ownership of the lunchtime
process as a personal matter. This new reality and the impact of taking
personal responsibility are driven home when the child is faced with
the dreaded obstacle of an unwanted piece of cauliflower or broccoli
that must be eaten. It is in these trying times that the child learns
some very important lessons that will benefit him or her in adulthood.
In essence, children learn that when the going gets tough, you often
have to suck it up, hold your nose, and face the undesirable task.
We see many similarities in the kitchen “plate
cleaning” challenge that are also present in our nation’s challenge to
protect the border. Currently, the issue of border security has been
pushed into the forefront of public debate. This is an issue that has
been lingering on America’s plate for a long time. However, since
September 11, 2001, a sense of urgency to deal with the issue of border
security has been rekindled. For decades, those who have petitioned for
tighter border security have cited the economic strain that illegal
aliens place on domestic jobs and social services. Others point to the
impact of crime that occurs when criminals from others countries are
allowed to run unchecked and un-monitored amongst the U.S. populace.
The current dilemma of an unprotected border now includes the terrorist
agent(s) and the fear building tools of terrorism, such as (WMD)
Weapons of Mass Destruction. Despite having a strong defensive strategy
abroad for fighting terrorism, America’s unwillingness to secure the
border leaves the country with a full plate of problems. Based from a
historical lack of political will, America can be likened to a stubborn
child, who by failing to cleanse his plate, must sit with his food and
wait for things to get so unbearable that actions is finally taken. The
very same thing that makes the stubborn child’s stand off so
aggravating to the parent is the same factor that makes border security
advocates angry with the government. That is, in both cases, the end
goal could be achieved within a few simple steps. That is, true border
security implementation, like plate cleaning, is not brain surgery; the
challenge is in having the will to complete the task. As with both
tasks, it is suggested that the simple but valuable logic of “A few
bites and you’re done” be forwarded. That is, break the task into
simple steps that linked together, achieve the desired goal.
The recipe for true border security is obvious and
simple: construct permanent physical barriers across the entire border,
deploy the military to the border with full detention authority, and
create a strict but fair immigration program for the future. Failing to
implement all of these programs will deny the country a truly secure
border leaving the problem for others to deal with. It is easy to fall
into the liberal trap that all issues are complex. If one falls into
this mental “Bermuda triangle”, simple constructions (such as a wall)
must be analyzed as to the possible “statement” someone on the opposite
side of the hemisphere may associate with it. Oh course a wall does
make a statement, “Don’t go past this point!” However, the failings of
liberal minded deliberation on border security is that it is perceived
that action cannot be taken unless it benefits border countries as
much, if not more, than the U.S. This can, and usually does lead to
inaction or just plan silly action.
The challenge of creating border security has now been laid upon the
president’s plate. Will the president deal with the problem once and
for all? Will the problem simply be swept to the side of the plate and
be followed by a presidential statement of “all done”? There is no
doubt that some will dispute securing the border. The current protests
in many large cities mark a bizarre version of that opposition in which
illegal aliens demand the rights of U.S. citizens. There is bound to be
additional opposition to securing the border from the Mexican
government. From our kitchen analogy, this is perfect time to avoid
worrying if Mexico will clean its own plate. We know the answer to this
question. Regardless of the opposition, the need for action is real,
the objective is obvious, and the time is now. Mr. President, secure
the border and end the decades of useless, cyclical talk about border
security. Don’t pass the problem on to another administration to deal
with - clean your plate! |